Difference between revisions of "MCDM Overview"

From COST Action FP0804: FORSYS
Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: require(): Unable to allocate memory for pool. in /data/home/fp0804/www/wiki/includes/AutoLoader.php on line 1191
(→‎Use of MCDM techniques in DSS: Overview)
 
(39 intermediate revisions by one user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
__TOC__
  
−
Overview of MCDM techniques:
+
== Overview of MCDM techniques ==
 
{{#ask:[[Category:MCDM methods]]
 
{{#ask:[[Category:MCDM methods]]
 
|?#
 
|?#
Line 10: Line 11:
 
}}
 
}}
  
 +
== Use of MCDM techniques in DSS ==
 +
DSSs using AWOT:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::AWOT]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
  
 
DSSs using Analytical Network Process (ANP):
 
DSSs using Analytical Network Process (ANP):
Line 21: Line 42:
 
}}
 
}}
  
−
DSSs using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP):
+
DSSs using Borda count:
−
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]]
+
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Borda count]]
 
|?#
 
|?#
 
|format=ol
 
|format=ol
Line 30: Line 51:
 
|columns=1
 
|columns=1
 
}}
 
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Compromise programming (CP):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Compromise programming (CP)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Direct point allocation:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Direct point allocation]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Fuzzy MCDM:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Analytical Network Process (ANP):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Network Process (ANP)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Goal programming (GP):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Matrix techniques:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Matrix techniques]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Multi-Criteria Approval:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Criteria Approval]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Multi-Criteria Risk Analysis (MCRA):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Criteria Risk Analysis (MCRA)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Multi-objective programming (MOP):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-objective programming (MOP)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Other continuous MCDM:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other continuous MCDM]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Other discrete MCDM:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other discrete MCDM]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Other multi-agent MCDM:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Outranking (Electre and Promethee):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Outranking (Electre and Promethee)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using SWOT:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::SWOT]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Simple multiple attribute ranking (SMART):
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Simple multiple attribute ranking (SMART)]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Simple ranking:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Simple ranking]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Value tree analysis:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Value tree analysis]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
DSSs using Voting:
 +
{{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Voting]]
 +
|?#
 +
|format=ol
 +
|link=all
 +
|headers=show
 +
|searchlabel=… further results
 +
|columns=1
 +
}}
 +
 +
== Use of MCDM techniques in DSSs: Overview ==
 +
Single use and multiple uses of MCDM techniques in DSSs (only techniques used in at least one DSS were taken into account)
 +
 +
{| class="wikitable"
 +
!
 +
! align="left"| Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)
 +
! Fuzzy MCDM
 +
! Goal programming (GP)
 +
! Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)
 +
! Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)
 +
! Other multi-agent MCDM
 +
|-
 +
| Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
|-
 +
| Fuzzy MCDM
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
|-
 +
| Goal programming (GP)
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
|-
 +
| Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
|-
 +
| Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
|-
 +
| Other multi-agent MCDM
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Fuzzy MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Goal programming (GP)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)]] |headers=hide }}
 +
| {{#ask:[[Category:DSS]][[Has decision support techniques.Has MCDM method::Other multi-agent MCDM]] |headers=hide }}
 +
|}

Latest revision as of 22:56, 11 June 2013

Overview of MCDM techniques

  1. AWOT (AWOT)
  2. Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) (Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP))
  3. Analytical Network Process (ANP) (Analytical Network Process (ANP))
  4. Borda count (Borda count)
  5. Compromise programming (CP) (Compromise programming (CP))
  6. Direct point allocation (Direct point allocation)
  7. Fuzzy MCDM (Fuzzy MCDM)
  8. Goal programming (GP) (Goal programming (GP))
  9. Matrix techniques (Matrix techniques)
  10. Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT) (Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT))
  11. Multi-Criteria Approval (Multi-Criteria Approval)
  12. Multi-Criteria Risk Analysis (MCRA) (Multi-Criteria Risk Analysis (MCRA))
  13. Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) (Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA))
  14. Multi-objective programming (MOP) (Multi-objective programming (MOP))
  15. N/A (N/A)
  16. Other continuous MCDM (Other continuous MCDM)
  17. Other discrete MCDM (Other discrete MCDM)
  18. Other multi-agent MCDM (Other multi-agent MCDM)
  19. Outranking (Electre and Promethee) (Outranking (Electre and Promethee))
  20. SWOT (SWOT)
  21. Simple multiple attribute ranking (SMART) (Simple multiple attribute ranking (SMART))
  22. Simple ranking (Simple ranking)
  23. Value tree analysis (Value tree analysis)
  24. Voting (Voting)


Use of MCDM techniques in DSS

DSSs using AWOT:


DSSs using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP):

  1. DSD (DSD)
  2. EMDS (EMDS)
  3. FORFUN (FORFUN)
  4. PYL (PYL)


DSSs using Analytical Network Process (ANP):

  1. MyTestDSS (MyTestDSS)


DSSs using Borda count:

  1. TestDSS (TestDSS)


DSSs using Compromise programming (CP):

  1. TestDSS (TestDSS)


DSSs using Direct point allocation:

  1. MyTestDSS (MyTestDSS)


DSSs using Fuzzy MCDM:

  1. EMDS (EMDS)


DSSs using Analytical Network Process (ANP):

  1. MyTestDSS (MyTestDSS)


DSSs using Goal programming (GP):

  1. OSMOSE (OSMOSE)


DSSs using Matrix techniques:


DSSs using Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT):

  1. CONES (CONES)
  2. DSD (DSD)


DSSs using Multi-Criteria Approval:


DSSs using Multi-Criteria Risk Analysis (MCRA):


DSSs using Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA):

  1. PractiSFM (PractiSFM)
  2. ToSIA (ToSIA)


DSSs using Multi-objective programming (MOP):


DSSs using Other continuous MCDM:


DSSs using Other discrete MCDM:


DSSs using Other multi-agent MCDM:

  1. Mesta (Mesta)
  2. PYL (PYL)


DSSs using Outranking (Electre and Promethee):


DSSs using SWOT:


DSSs using Simple multiple attribute ranking (SMART):


DSSs using Simple ranking:


DSSs using Value tree analysis:


DSSs using Voting:


Use of MCDM techniques in DSSs: Overview

Single use and multiple uses of MCDM techniques in DSSs (only techniques used in at least one DSS were taken into account)

Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) Fuzzy MCDM Goal programming (GP) Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT) Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) Other multi-agent MCDM
Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) DSD, EMDS, FORFUN, PYL EMDS DSD PYL
Fuzzy MCDM EMDS EMDS
Goal programming (GP) OSMOSE
Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT) DSD CONES, DSD
Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) PractiSFM, ToSIA
Other multi-agent MCDM PYL Mesta, PYL
Retrieved from "http://fp0804.emu.ee/wiki/index.php?title=MCDM_Overview&oldid=9897"