Difference between revisions of "NED"

Warning: require(): Unable to allocate memory for pool. in /data/home/fp0804/www/wiki/includes/AutoLoader.php on line 1191

Revision as of 12:36, 8 September 2009 (view source) Francisco Girón Gesteira (Talk | contribs) (Creation, quite complete)		Latest revision as of 07:56, 14 October 2012 (view source) Ola Eriksson (Talk | contribs)
(20 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 3:		Line 3:
	System name: NED		System name: NED
−	What does NED stand for: NED was originally an acronym for the northeast decision model; however, since 1995 when development was expanded to include other regions of North America, the reference to the northeastern United States was dropped, and the name is now simply NED.	+	NED was originally an acronym for the northeast decision model; however, since 1995 when development was expanded to include other regions of North America, the reference to the northeastern United States was dropped, and the name is now simply NED.
−		+
−	Web page: http://www.fs.fed.us/ne/burlington/ned	+
	=== Brief overview ===		=== Brief overview ===
	NED is a set of computer-based tools for forest ecosystem management designed to allow the analysis of the trade-offs required when managing for multiple benefits.		NED is a set of computer-based tools for forest ecosystem management designed to allow the analysis of the trade-offs required when managing for multiple benefits.
		+	[[Category:Decision support system]]
	[[Category:USA DSS]]		[[Category:USA DSS]]
		+	[[Image:Image007.jpg|thumb|NED logo]]
	__TOC__		__TOC__
	=== Scope of the system ===		=== Scope of the system ===
−	The primary tool is a DSS designed for proffesional forest managers to evaluate current and future conditions of their forest under alternative scenarios. Additional tools are usable by general public, school children, and forest landowners. These tools include the forest stewardship plan, NEWPLAN, StewPlan and NEDLite.	+	NED-2 is a DSS designed to help professional forest managers to evaluate current and future conditions of their forest under alternative scenarios. It uses a goal-driven approach to the analysis of inventory data and simulated plans, which distinguishes NED-2 from other available DSS or inventory processing tools. Additional tools are usable by general public, school children, and forest landowners.
−	NED-2 uses a goal-driven approach to the analysis of inventory data and simulated plans, that distinguishes NED-2 from other available DSS or inventory processing tools.	+
	=== System origin ===		=== System origin ===
	* Development has been led by USDA Forest Service's Northeastern Research Station, but includes many collaborators from other federal agencies, universities, state governments and private consulting foresters throughout the eastern United States.		* Development has been led by USDA Forest Service's Northeastern Research Station, but includes many collaborators from other federal agencies, universities, state governments and private consulting foresters throughout the eastern United States.
	* NED has been developed as a goal-driven system with the intent of providing useful and scientifically credible information for project-level planning to natural resources managers.		* NED has been developed as a goal-driven system with the intent of providing useful and scientifically credible information for project-level planning to natural resources managers.
−	* It is free to download at the [http://www.fs.fed.us/ne/burlington/ned NED website]
−	* The primarily application of NED software is among private consulting foresters in the eastern United States, where regular users number in the hundreds. The software is also used extensively in forestry classrooms in colleges and universities.
	=== Support for specific issues  ===		=== Support for specific issues  ===
Line 37:		Line 34:
	=== Capability to support decision making phases  ===		=== Capability to support decision making phases  ===
−	''(NOTE I do not quite know what to do with this, as I do not understand it myself, although it seems related to system use)''	+
−	* Intelligence (+ explicit description of the support given by the DSS)	+	[Intelligence, Design, Choice, Monitoring <ref>http://fp0804.emu.ee/wiki/index.php/Simon%27s_decision_making_model</ref>]
−	* Design (+ explicit description of the support given by the DSS)	+
−	* Choice (+ explicit description of the support given by the DSS)	+	* Intelligence: helps identify and capture management goals
−	* Monitor (+ explicit description of the support given by the DSS)	+	* Design: provides recommendations on treatments for progressing toward management goals
		+	* Choice: helps evaluate the extent to which alternative treatments attain management goals
		+	* Monitor: ???
	=== Related systems  ===		=== Related systems  ===
−	* [[SVS]]	+	* Stand Visualization System (SVS): used to visualize results at the stand level
−	* [[FVS]]	+	* [[FVS]]: growth and yield simulator
−	NED tools:	+
−	* [[NED/Forest stewardship plan|Forest stewardship plan]]	+
−	* [[NED/NEWPLAN|NEWPLAN]]	+
−	* [[NED/StewPlan|StewPlan]]	+
−	* [[NED/NEDLite|NEDLite]]	+
		+	Other NED tools:
		+	* STEWPLAN: Forest stewardship planner
		+	* NEDLite: software that enables field data collection on handheld computers/PDAs with automatic data transfer into NED for analysis
		+	* NEWILD: evaluates the habitat suitability of stand inventory data by comparing them to a set of species/habitat matrices
	== Data and data models ==		== Data and data models ==
Line 63:		Line 61:
	=== Type of information input from user (via GUI) ===		=== Type of information input from user (via GUI) ===
−	The users have to address their goals within the [[#Support for specific issues | above]] mentioned ones.	+	The users have to address their goals within the [[#Support for specific issues |above]] mentioned ones.
−	<span style="color:red">
	== Models ==		== Models ==
	=== Forest models ===		=== Forest models ===
−	Growth, Yield, Carbon, Wood quality, biodiversity and habitat suitability, environmental and external effects (fire, storms, pests, diseases, climate change, etc)	+
		+	NED-2 doesn't do the actual forest growth simulation, but it controls the flow of data to and from external forest simulation models that are installed with NED-2 (typically regional [[FVS]] variants).
	=== Social models  ===		=== Social models  ===
−	historical and cultural values of sites, values due to peace and quiet, esthetic values, values due to recreational activities, ethical values): E. g. Recreation, Health, Game
		+	NED-2 provides the user with a number of alternative algorithms for translating inventory data into attainment measures for each resource goal (visual quality, wildlife, water, wood production, and general ecological objectives). For example, the following metrics are possible for evaluating water quality:
		+
		+	* Meet Best Management Practices
		+	* Provide Intensive Protection of Water Resources
		+	* Provide Intensive Protection of Wetlands
		+	* Provide Protection of Riparian Areas
		+	* Enhance Habitat for Warm Water Fish
		+	* Enhance Habitat for Cold Water Fish
	== Decision Support ==		== Decision Support ==
Line 83:		Line 88:
	=== Typical temporal scale of application ===		=== Typical temporal scale of application ===
−	Define the temporal scale of the application: E.g., operational and immediate level, Tactical planning (short term) and strategic level.	+
		+	Goals can be used as longer-term strategic or shorter-term tactical targets.
	=== Types of decisions supported  ===		=== Types of decisions supported  ===
Line 110:		Line 116:
	*Multiple criteria/ranking		*Multiple criteria/ranking
	*Other		*Other
−	</span>
Line 116:		Line 121:
	=== Types of  outputs ===		=== Types of  outputs ===
−	<span style="color:red">RESULTS</span>
−	Besides the showed results in the own application, it includes some data export functions; an export function to ArcMap (the NED analysis itself is not spatially explicit, but it does include this export function of summarized data as attribute layers) and the capability to create some third-party external models for the FVS growth simulator and for the SVS data visualization package.	+	NED-2 produces a report in HTML format that indicates whether each goal has succeeded or failed, including details on each of the conditions in the analysis. It also provides a wide variety of standardized reports on vegetation attributes and associate values.
	=== Spatial analysis capabilities  ===		=== Spatial analysis capabilities  ===
−	* integrated capabilities	+
−	* facilitates links to GIS (wizards, etc.)	+	NED-2 can link to the ArcMap GIS system to 1) display results spatially, and 2) identify stand adjacencies and then use this information to report some patch measures.
−	* provides standard data import/export formats	+
−	* allows spatial analysis (e.g. topology overlays (e.g. multi layering of different maps, selection of objects based on selection criteria, aggregation by attributes (e.g. areas of similar characteristics), Linking by logical means, Statistics by area, analysis with digital terrain model)	+
	=== Abilities to address interdisciplinary, multi-scaled, and political issues  ===		=== Abilities to address interdisciplinary, multi-scaled, and political issues  ===
−	Evaluate interactions between different basic information types (biophysical, economic, social). Produce coordinated results for decision makers operating at different spatial scales facilitate social negotiation and learning	+	* [Evaluate interactions between different basic information types (biophysical, economic, social)]
		+	* [Produce coordinated results for decision makers operating at different spatial scales]
		+	* [Facilitate social negotiation and learning]
		+	NED-2 evaluates interactions between different basic information types (biophysical, economic, social) through its application of user goals to evaluation of the biophysical resources.
	== System ==		== System ==
	=== System requirements  ===		=== System requirements  ===
−	* Operating Systems: Microsoft Windows OS	+	* Operating Systems: Microsoft Windows 2000, XP
−	* Other software needed: The inventories input data file format is .mdb, a Microsoft Access database, although MS Access being not required to run NED. For the third-party external models, external software such as [[FVS]], [[SVS]] or [[ArcGIS]] is required.	+	* Other software needed: The inventories input data file format is .mdb, a Microsoft Access database, although MS Access being not required to run NED. For the third-party external models, external software such as [[FVS]], SVS or ArcGIS is required.
	* Development status: version 2.0 is now available.		* Development status: version 2.0 is now available.
Line 141:		Line 146:
	=== Usage ===		=== Usage ===
−	It is used among private consulting foresters, and also in classrooms in Colleges and Universities ([[#System origin |see]]).
−	<span style="color:red">	+	* The primarily application of NED software is among private consulting foresters in the eastern United States, where regular users number in the hundreds. The software is also used extensively in forestry classrooms in colleges and universities.
	=== Computational limitations ===		=== Computational limitations ===
−	Describe the system limitations: e.g. number of management units, number of vehicles, time horizon	+
		+	* You cannot have more than 99 plots in any stand.
		+	* You cannot have more than 999 records in one cluster.
		+	* You cannot have more than 1350 records for stems >= 1 inch dbh in the overstory and understory combined.
	=== User interface ===		=== User interface ===
−	Describe the quality of user interface and the Prerequisite knowledge for using the system	+
		+	Has a well-developed Windows interface.
	=== Documentation and support ===		=== Documentation and support ===
−	Describe the connection to Help-system and possibilities for assistance, as well as the required training and user support levels	+
		+	Has an integrated Windows-style help system and comes with sample data.
	=== Installation ===		=== Installation ===
	* Prerequisite knowledge: Level of effort to become functional		* Prerequisite knowledge: Level of effort to become functional
−	* Cost: (purchase price, development costs, demonstrated return on investment, cost of use, training costs, licence and maintenance costs)	+	* Cost: free to download at the NED website
−	* Demo: allows the download/utilization of a trial version. If yes, where is it available and what are the trial conditions.	+
−		+
−	</span>	+
	==References==		==References==
Line 167:		Line 173:
	===External resources===		===External resources===
		+
		+	Web page: http://nrs.fs.fed.us/tools/ned/products/ned2/
	REYNOLDS K.M., TWERY M., LEXER M.J., VACIK H., RAY D., SHAO G,. et BORGES J.G.: ''Decision Support Systems in Forest Management'' IN BURSTEIN F. et HOLSAPPLE C. W. (EDS.) (2008): ''Handbook on Decision Support Systems 2: Variations''. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. 800 pp.		REYNOLDS K.M., TWERY M., LEXER M.J., VACIK H., RAY D., SHAO G,. et BORGES J.G.: ''Decision Support Systems in Forest Management'' IN BURSTEIN F. et HOLSAPPLE C. W. (EDS.) (2008): ''Handbook on Decision Support Systems 2: Variations''. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. 800 pp.
		+
		+	Twery, Mark J.; Knopp, Peter D.; Thomasma, Scott A.; Rauscher, H. Michael; Nute, Donald E.; Potter, Walter D.; Maier, Frederick; Wang, Jin; Dass, Mayukh; Uchiyama, Hajime; Glende, Astrid; Hoffman, Robin E. 2005. NED-2: A decision support system for integrated forest ecosystem management. Elsevier, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture. 49:24-43.
		+
		+	Nute, Donald; Potter, Walter D.; Maier, Frederick; Wang, Jin; Twery, Mark; Rauscher, H. Michael; Knopp, Peter; Thomasma, Scott; Dass, Mayukh; Uchiyama, Hajime; Glende, Astride. 2004. NED-2: an agent-based decision support system for forest ecosystem management. Elsevier, Environmental Modeling and Software 19:831-843.

---

Latest revision as of 07:56, 14 October 2012

General System description

System name: NED

NED was originally an acronym for the northeast decision model; however, since 1995 when development was expanded to include other regions of North America, the reference to the northeastern United States was dropped, and the name is now simply NED.

Brief overview

NED is a set of computer-based tools for forest ecosystem management designed to allow the analysis of the trade-offs required when managing for multiple benefits.

Scope of the system

NED-2 is a DSS designed to help professional forest managers to evaluate current and future conditions of their forest under alternative scenarios. It uses a goal-driven approach to the analysis of inventory data and simulated plans, which distinguishes NED-2 from other available DSS or inventory processing tools. Additional tools are usable by general public, school children, and forest landowners.

System origin

• Development has been led by USDA Forest Service's Northeastern Research Station, but includes many collaborators from other federal agencies, universities, state governments and private consulting foresters throughout the eastern United States.
• NED has been developed as a goal-driven system with the intent of providing useful and scientifically credible information for project-level planning to natural resources managers.

Support for specific issues

The resource goals addressed by NED include timber production, visual qualities, water quality and quantity, wildlife habitat, forest health, and ecology.

Support for specific thematic areas of a problem type

• Silvicultural
• Certification
• Conservation
• Restoration
• Development choices / land use zoning
• Policy/intervention alternatives
• Sustainability impact assessment (SIA)

Capability to support decision making phases

[Intelligence, Design, Choice, Monitoring ^[1]]

• Intelligence: helps identify and capture management goals
• Design: provides recommendations on treatments for progressing toward management goals
• Choice: helps evaluate the extent to which alternative treatments attain management goals
• Monitor: ???

Related systems

• Stand Visualization System (SVS): used to visualize results at the stand level
• FVS: growth and yield simulator

Other NED tools:

• STEWPLAN: Forest stewardship planner
• NEDLite: software that enables field data collection on handheld computers/PDAs with automatic data transfer into NED for analysis
• NEWILD: evaluates the habitat suitability of stand inventory data by comparing them to a set of species/habitat matrices

Data and data models

Typical spatial extent of application

Both forest and stand level. The system design allows including inventories from multiple stands within a property or management unit.

Forest data input

Depending on the users' objectives. To enable analyses for the full variety of resources a fairly detailed inventory of the forested property is needed, usually including plot data from trees, shrubs, ground flora, and down woody material, but NED will also run with minimal data sets if the user only wants timber inventory summaries, for example. There is also an import facility to allow the conversion of data files generated elsewhere that have been converted to formatted text to be imported into NED 2.

Type of information input from user (via GUI)

The users have to address their goals within the above mentioned ones.

Models

Forest models

NED-2 doesn't do the actual forest growth simulation, but it controls the flow of data to and from external forest simulation models that are installed with NED-2 (typically regional FVS variants).

Social models

NED-2 provides the user with a number of alternative algorithms for translating inventory data into attainment measures for each resource goal (visual quality, wildlife, water, wood production, and general ecological objectives). For example, the following metrics are possible for evaluating water quality:

• Meet Best Management Practices
• Provide Intensive Protection of Water Resources
• Provide Intensive Protection of Wetlands
• Provide Protection of Riparian Areas
• Enhance Habitat for Warm Water Fish
• Enhance Habitat for Cold Water Fish

Decision Support

Definition of management interventions

Define what is available for the manager to intervene in the forest: time of harvest, plantations, thinnings, reconversions... Existence of prescription writer, simple enumeration of all possibilities, scenario simulation , etc.

Typical temporal scale of application

Goals can be used as longer-term strategic or shorter-term tactical targets.

Types of decisions supported

• Management level
  • strategic decisions
  • administrative decisions
  • operating control decisions
• Management function
• planning decisions
  • organizing decisions
  • command decisions
  • control decisions
  • coordination decisions
• decision making situation
  • unilateral
  • collegial
  • Bargaining / participative decision making

Decision-making processes and models

• Logic modeling
• Operations research modeling
  • Direct approaches
  • Heuristic manipulation of simulation models
• Business modeling
• Simulation (with and without stochasticity)
• Multiple criteria/ranking
• Other

Output

Types of outputs

NED-2 produces a report in HTML format that indicates whether each goal has succeeded or failed, including details on each of the conditions in the analysis. It also provides a wide variety of standardized reports on vegetation attributes and associate values.

Spatial analysis capabilities

NED-2 can link to the ArcMap GIS system to 1) display results spatially, and 2) identify stand adjacencies and then use this information to report some patch measures.

Abilities to address interdisciplinary, multi-scaled, and political issues

• [Evaluate interactions between different basic information types (biophysical, economic, social)]
• [Produce coordinated results for decision makers operating at different spatial scales]
• [Facilitate social negotiation and learning]

NED-2 evaluates interactions between different basic information types (biophysical, economic, social) through its application of user goals to evaluation of the biophysical resources.

System

System requirements

• Operating Systems: Microsoft Windows 2000, XP
• Other software needed: The inventories input data file format is .mdb, a Microsoft Access database, although MS Access being not required to run NED. For the third-party external models, external software such as FVS, SVS or ArcGIS is required.
• Development status: version 2.0 is now available.

Architecture and major DSS components

The software interface is written in C++ and uses Prolog components to manage the knowledge bases and the handling of third-party external models, such as the FVS growth simulator, the SVS data visualization package, and ArcGIS.

Usage

• The primarily application of NED software is among private consulting foresters in the eastern United States, where regular users number in the hundreds. The software is also used extensively in forestry classrooms in colleges and universities.

Computational limitations

• You cannot have more than 99 plots in any stand.
• You cannot have more than 999 records in one cluster.
• You cannot have more than 1350 records for stems >= 1 inch dbh in the overstory and understory combined.

User interface

Has a well-developed Windows interface.

Documentation and support

Has an integrated Windows-style help system and comes with sample data.

Installation

• Prerequisite knowledge: Level of effort to become functional
• Cost: free to download at the NED website

References

Cited references

1. ↑ http://fp0804.emu.ee/wiki/index.php/Simon%27s_decision_making_model

External resources

Web page: http://nrs.fs.fed.us/tools/ned/products/ned2/

REYNOLDS K.M., TWERY M., LEXER M.J., VACIK H., RAY D., SHAO G,. et BORGES J.G.: Decision Support Systems in Forest Management IN BURSTEIN F. et HOLSAPPLE C. W. (EDS.) (2008): Handbook on Decision Support Systems 2: Variations. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. 800 pp.

Twery, Mark J.; Knopp, Peter D.; Thomasma, Scott A.; Rauscher, H. Michael; Nute, Donald E.; Potter, Walter D.; Maier, Frederick; Wang, Jin; Dass, Mayukh; Uchiyama, Hajime; Glende, Astrid; Hoffman, Robin E. 2005. NED-2: A decision support system for integrated forest ecosystem management. Elsevier, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture. 49:24-43.

Nute, Donald; Potter, Walter D.; Maier, Frederick; Wang, Jin; Twery, Mark; Rauscher, H. Michael; Knopp, Peter; Thomasma, Scott; Dass, Mayukh; Uchiyama, Hajime; Glende, Astride. 2004. NED-2: an agent-based decision support system for forest ecosystem management. Elsevier, Environmental Modeling and Software 19:831-843.