Case Lessons by actor

From COST Action FP0804: FORSYS
Jump to: navigation, search
Has actor perspectiveHas researcher roleHas developer roleHas user roleLessonHas related case
Developer/Architect
User
A more informative output should be generated with clear graphs and maps indicating long-term
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Actor Network Theory provides a suitable lens for exploring both technical and human aspects of DSS institutionalization in the forestry domain
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Adapting the software to make it possible to easily include also the output of other mechanistic
Developer/ArchitectAfforestion and deforestation options should be included in the management options
Developer/Architect
Researcher
An optimisation module comparing alternative scenarios based on multi-criteria analysis should be
Developer/ArchitectAs the core of forest DSS are models describing the development of trees and stands (growth and
Developer/Architect
Researcher
User
DSS can help in varying the treatment according to more than one forest function
Developer/Architect
User
Embedding a DSS in a GIS software allows obtaining information at different spatial scales using the
Developer/ArchitectEnabling the analyses of several ecosystem services (timber and non-timber resources) in one and the
Developer/Architect
Researcher
User
Architect
Programmer
Project manager
Decision maker
Forest manager
Stakeholders
Enlarge the decision space by generating a large set of potential management alternatives
Developer/Architect
Researcher
User
Decision analyst
Modeler
ArchitectForest manager
Decision maker
Enlarged decision space
Developer/ArchitectArchitectForest managers have to analyze how their forest management interventions effect the landscape
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Project managerGetting joint funding from both the forest and environmental sectors can be a successfull for
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Interpretative case studies can help reduce the gap between research and practice
Developer/Architect
User
It should be possible to specify the rotation time of a species not only by age but also by target
Developer/Architect
Facilitator
User
It would have been better to involve some end users at earlier stages of the system development
Developer/Architect
Facilitator
User
Lack of proper documentation and support services (manual, website, etc) can severely limit the
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Modular approach helpful in assisting industry uptake
Developer/ArchitectNeed of flexibilization of analytical tools - no overdesigned tool that provides too much features for the use
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Neighbourhood interrelations should be included in the generator
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Operational aspects of the system should be enhanced
Developer/Architect
Researcher
User
Decision analystArchitect
Project manager
Decision maker
Forest manager
Stakeholders
Pareto Frontier Techniques are useful for multi-criteria forest management planning
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Plan the system architecture based on a broad view of future possibilities
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Decision analyst
Modeler
Architect
Project manager
Provide missing help-documentation service
Developer/ArchitectProviding procedures and structure for data flow from selection of field sample, performing field
Developer/Architect
User
ArchitectForest manager
Stakeholders
The DSS models built must match the knowledge of the local forest managers, so the ability for local
Developer/ArchitectThe ProgettoBosco working methodology, based on cooperation, successive approximations and
Developer/ArchitectThe adoption of the collaborative learning method made possible to gradually select the conceptual
Developer/Architect
Researcher
The analysis of the actor network interactions allowed to identify the criticalities to be solved in order to develop the collaborative process
Developer/Architect
Researcher
The choice to develop the system in an Excel environment was based on the status of computer
Developer/Architect
Researcher
The definition of standardized and specific criteria for selecting and zoning forest compartment
Developer/ArchitectThe development of large and enduring systems requires a long term approach
Developer/Architect
Researcher
The fact that ProgettoBosco is conceived according to the criteria and indicators of sustainable
Developer/Architect
User
The kinds of DSS traditionally used to calculate timber harvest levels are now being used to model
Developer/Architect
Researcher
The tracing of the actor network supported the identification of the key actors influencing the collaborative DSS implementation and institutionalization
Developer/Architect
Researcher
The tracing of the current actor network interactions made the group realize that they need a different kind of stakeholders from what they previously thought
Developer/Architect
User
The use of structured output (maps, tables and charts) makes the methodology and the results more
Developer/Architect
User
The very easy user-friendly interface of the software and the clearness of method can be exploited
Developer/Architect
User
To compare the current and the past quantitative-qualitative parameters of the forest, great effort
Developer/Architect
Facilitator
To meet the needs of customer - the Forest Service - and to obtain satisfying results the
Developer/Architect
User
Users preferred enhanced functionality rather than useability
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Decision analystUsing Actor Network Theory in the design stage can help in understanding the dynamism of the network
Developer/Architect
Researcher
Decision analyst
Modeler
Visualization of the preliminary actor network made the people explicity include the DSS in a planning process
Facilitator
Researcher
ModelerAn iterative process of presenting results to subject matter experts enabled them to better
FacilitatorAnalysis at the landscape level allowed the integration of concerns about multiple resources as well
Facilitator
User
DSS allowed to explain better some technical concepts to non-professional stakeholders
Facilitator
User
StakeholdersDSS helped document and apply decision criteria consistently, and therefore produced a more
Facilitator
User
Despite the widely use and acceptance of the DSS there was still a lack of expertise to
Facilitator
User
From a management perspective, to avoid the complication of testing something new, the models used
Facilitator
Researcher
Decision analystModel building was rapid, it was assembling the data that took by far the most time
Facilitator
User
Need of a moderator function
Facilitator
User
Requirement of specialized skills can discourage some potential users
Facilitator
User
Running the DSS required special skills, therefore the local planning team required considerable
Facilitator
User
SIPAFIT can act sometimes as a referee to settle arguments among experts, users and stakeholders
Facilitator
Researcher
User
SIPAFIT sub-systems have been useful in training activities, and can be very useful to explain and
Facilitator
Researcher
Decision analystSpatial variation between regions led to the development of different regional models, which led to
Facilitator
User
Stakeholders contribution in ranking forest functions
Facilitator
User
Forest manager
Stakeholders
The DSS usage enabled the planning team to measure the achievement of the restoration goals
Facilitator
User
StakeholdersThe activation of an iterative process through periodical meetings permitted to all the stakeholders
Facilitator
User
The scope of the modeling project can change significantly during the project
Facilitator
Researcher
Decision analyst
Modeler
Forest managerThe software did not provide much support for formatting of the outputs in a format that could be
FacilitatorThe use of the DSS improved communication among the planning team by providing a framework of the
FacilitatorUse of the DSS has been considered successful by the participating organizations, even though it has
Researcher
User
Decision analyst
Modeler
Forest managerEnd user engagement throughout the development and deployment cycle is very important
Researcher
User
Decision analyst
Modeler
Forest manager
Decision maker
Projection of stand development increases knowledge base
Researcher
User
Regular ongoing engagement helped maintain interest of users
ResearcherStudents studying forest management planning procedures and processes were very useful product testers
ResearcherDecision analyst
Modeler
The analysis team used internal prototyping, which helped train the staff and identify possible
UserMultiple DSS are often needed to meet complex needs
UserProvide a simple version of the DSS, which new users can try out and learn quickly
UserForest managerThe DSS gave the forest manager the opportunity to experiment how their emphasis towards certain
UserForest managerThe use of EMDS allowed the planning team to identify priority area for restoration treatments that
UserThe user has to be aware of the possibly large impact that the chosen land indicators and threshold